shadow above body
Browse by...
left bar divider

Contact us

Tired of the waste and stupidity? Tell us what you've witnessed.

 

Government Blog Directory

On The Horizon

Can a car be too quiet?

Those addicted to the comical Showtime series Weeds will recall a scene in which the gangster named "U-turn" purchases a fleet of hybrid-electric Toyota Priuses so he could use their stealth for drive-by shootings in South L.A.  But the dark comedy in the vehicle's quiet ways is no laughing matter for some California state legislators who worry these types of cars are too dangerous for blind people.

State Senator Alan Lowenthal, a Democrat from Long Beach, CA, is trying to enact a bill aimed at making these four-wheeled eco-saviors louder.  Lowenthal believes that at present, the cars don't make enough noise to be heard by the blind and visually impaired as they are trying to cross the street. 

Unfortunately, there's no data to support or reject Lowenthals claims that hybrid drivers are a menace to the visually impaired as state traffic officials don't keep statistics on pedestrian accidents involving hybrid or electric vehicles. But anecdotal evidence is easy to find. Just ask anyone with a stalking X-girlfriend how many times a night he sees rather than hears that Prius drive by his house.

To gain some perspective, the state Senate approved a bill this week to study the issue and recommend ways to make the hybrids louder. Of course, anyone who has taken physics might recall that noise is an indicator of inefficiency and energy use. So the more noise an engine makes, the less efficient it is. Sorry Harley lovers. 

It's conceivable some sort of small, whistling device run by wind streaming through it (think deer alerts) could be installed on the vehicles to give them a noise. Surely that would make them even more beloved by SUV drivers than they are today. The question is whether owners or car manufacturers will end up burdened with the extra cost of a new contraption. Given the state's legislative history, car manufactures would be the safer bet.

Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger has not yet taken a position on the bill which awaits his signature. Whatever the decision, it's likely other states will follow California's lead. In the meantime, hybrid and electric car drivers should impose the other safety precaution for dealing with their silent rides: trying not to run over any blind people.


Also Interesting:

The parking ticket that turned one man homeless
Greening the Gov: Oregon greening its highways
New law attempting to censor Internet use
Denver passes ordinance to keep illegal aliens from driving
South Dakota to hold vote on abortion ban


Published Aug 29 2008, 08:41 AM by Andrew B. Einhorn |  Email |  Print



Comments

State and Local said:

How much would your job need to pay for you to move to Alaska? If you're a police officer from Minnesota

August 29, 2008 9:55 AM
kerry bradshaw said:
I'd say that if a blind person expects to avoid cars by listening for them, he/she has more problems than simply not being able to se.
August 29, 2008 10:48 AM
Bob Wilson said:
The pedestrian traffic accident data is kept by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) for the whole country and an analysis is available from www.regulations.gov - search NHTSA-2008-0108-0020. Dr. Christopher Hogan analyzed all available traffic data covering the years of Prius hybrid electric operation and found: (1) identical rate of pedestrian accidents, and (2) no blind has ever been killed by a Prius, yet. The California bill is a duplicate of HR 5734, we call the "Bell the Hybrid Act," so California tax payers will pay twice: (1) state taxes for Lowenthal's study, and (2) federal taxes for HR 5734. We recommend contacting the California governor's office and pointing out that paying twice for the same study is a waste of California tax payer money. HR 5734 has a number of other problems with the facts and data. No only were the available traffic data ignored but the proposed solution, adding noise makers, is exactly what kills 5 blind out of 4,700 pedestrian deaths each year. Legislating an ineffective noisemaker just ensures that someday, the last thing someone hears is the Lowenthal faux noise maker ... before their bones are crushed. As written the California bill and HR 5734 are rubbish. Bob Wilson, Huntsville, AL
August 29, 2008 12:30 PM
kev scotland said:
We are missing a great opportunity here with electric cars to reduce noise pollution i am all for it. get those noise cars off or streets, a better proposal is to give registered blind a device that can deter cars and emitts a sound in there ear only they can hear. best of both worlds help blind protect themselves and others enjoy peace and quiet dont let idiots spoil it with easy cope out lazy solutions that have not been thought through such as make electrics louder for everyone
August 29, 2008 6:01 PM
Oil and gas heating up Congressional debates - On The Horizon said:

Pingback from  Oil and gas heating up Congressional debates - On The Horizon

September 5, 2008 2:34 PM
How green are America's counties? - On The Horizon said:

Pingback from  How green are America's counties? - On The Horizon

September 8, 2008 11:48 AM
CA legislating innovative smart growth strategies to combat pollution, traffic - State and Local said:

Pingback from  CA legislating innovative smart growth strategies to combat pollution, traffic - State and Local

September 12, 2008 10:41 AM

Leave a Comment

 (required)

 
 (optional)

 (required)

 
Add
Inside OhMyGov!

Have your own story or thought to share with others?

We'd love to hear it.  Just send us your story.

If after reviewing it we feel it's web worthy, we'll publish it here.  You get to decide if you want your name on it or not.

Just have a tip to share? Do it securely...

right bar divider
right bar divider
Book Nook

OhMyGov! review:

How to Land a Top-Paying Federal Job


By Lily Whiteman

 

 

A proud supporter of:

 

 

Add OhMyGov! to your website
Just click "get widget" below

 

Show some OhMyGov! love
Add us to your blog or website

 

 

Join us on
Click Me!
And get social with others

 

right bar divider
right bar divider
far right divider


 

 See All